French Channel CNews Criticized for Islamophobic Remarks Against Nuhaila Benzina’s Hijab at the 2023 Women’s World Cup
Introduction
French channel CNews has faced heavy criticism for making Islamophobic remarks against Moroccan soccer player Nuhaila Benzina. Benzina made the innovative decision to wear a hijab during the 2023 Women’s World Cup.
Philippe Guibert’s Offensive Commentary
Columnist Philippe Guibert’s comments on the HDPros show not only criticized Benzina’s choice, but also launched a scathing attack, calling the hijab an “incredible regression.”
Narrow Definition of Modesty
Guibert’s offensive remarks suggested that Benzina’s hijab sent a message of indiscretion to her teammates, implying that it meant a woman’s duty to cover her hair, shoulders, and overall figure in order to be considered modest.
Controversy and Outrage
This attempt to impose a narrow definition of modesty across cultures and religious practices has sparked controversy, leaving fans and viewers dismayed.
Impact on Diversity and Inclusion
Benzina’s historic moment as the first player to wear a hijab in a prestigious tournament was meant to celebrate diversity and inclusion. However, CNews’ comments overshadowed this significant event and cast a shadow on the spirit of global unity that the World Cup represents.
Outrage on Social Media
As news of Guibert’s announcement spread, outrage swept through social media, with many denouncing CNews’ attempt to project France’s controversial ban on religious symbols onto an athlete from another country and a tournament hosted outside of France.
Perpetuating Harmful Stereotypes
Many argue that such remarks perpetuate harmful stereotypes and Islamophobic attitudes towards women who choose to wear the hijab. They stress the need to respect different cultures and religious practices without imposing one’s own beliefs.
Men Dictating Women’s Clothing Choices
Some social media users highlight the absurdity of men taking it upon themselves to dictate women’s clothing choices. They express support for Benzina and her playmates who do not see her hijab in the same negative light.
French Media’s Regressive Approach
This incident exposes a discrepancy between the French media and other Western media. While international platforms have celebrated Benzina’s historic moment as a positive step towards inclusiveness and diversity in women’s football, the French media, including CNews, have taken a regressive approach.
Projection of National Agenda
CNews is not the only media outlet projecting France’s national agenda and internal debate about religious symbols onto international athletes from different cultures. L’Equipe, the famous French sports newspaper, has also added fuel to the fire by calling Benzina’s hijab “highly controversial.”